College Policy Debate Forums
April 22, 2019, 04:25:57 AM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?

Login with username, password and session length
News: IF YOU EXPERIENCE PROBLEMS WITH THE SITE, INCLUDING LOGGING IN, PLEASE LET ME KNOW IMMEDIATELY.  EMAIL ME DIRECTLY OR USE THE CONTACT US LINK AT THE TOP.
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: [1]
  Print  
Author Topic: 2010 Madison Cup Invitation  (Read 2807 times)
Mike Davis
Full Member
***
Posts: 238


« on: February 02, 2010, 09:35:49 PM »

January 15, 2010

On behalf of the James Madison Center and JMU Debate we are pleased and excited to invite you to compete for the Madison Cup at the eighth annual “James Madison Commemorative Debate and Citizens Forum” on Wednesday, April 21st, 2010.

The James Madison Commemorative Debate and Citizens Forum is a unique inter-collegiate debate competition which combines the excitement and challenge of tournament competition with the relevance and empowerment of a public audience and audience participation.   It is also one of the showcase events of our university’s James Madison Day Celebration.

There are many exciting changes this year thanks to a new partnership with The Arthur N. Rupe Foundation. These changes include: increased prize money (including student prize money), a more convenient date and a West Coast qualifying tournament.

2010 Topic: This house believes that the United States should officially recognize that health care is a right, and that its people should have access to a health care system that is universal, equitable and accountable. Other cool and unique features:

   *$28,000.00 in prize money
   *Debating and competing in front of public audiences
   *No entry fees
   *Continental breakfast, snacks and lunch provided
   *Video web-cast
   *Great PR for your debate program


The tournament details are enclosed with this letter.  If you should have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us.

We look forward to hosting you in April!

Mike Davis, Ph. D.               Pete Bsumek, Ph.D.
Co-Director, Madison Cup Debates         Co-Director, Madison Cup Debates
School of Comm. Studies            School of Comm. Studies
James Madison University            James Madison University
(O) 540-568-7308               (O) 540-568-3386
(E-mail) davismk@jmu.edu            (E-mail) bsumekpk@jmu.edu
 


Background: The James Madison Center at James Madison University sponsors the event in the spirit of James Madison's ideal that a republican democracy is healthy only when informed and civil debate thrives. The final round will be broadcast live on the World Wide Web.  Last year’s debate featured teams from Appalachian State University, Brown University, Cornell University, George Mason University, James Madison University, Johns Hopkins University, Liberty University, Piedmont College, Towson University, University of Mary Washington, University of Richmond, Wake Forest University, and Yale University.

We are excited to welcome a new sponsor this year. The Arthur N. Rupe Foundation has agreed to serve as the sponsor for the 2010 Madison Cup and we are humbled by their commitment to furthering public debate. They agreed to maintain the current team awards, while adding a West Coast qualifier (more details from our West Coast host shortly) and student awards.

Additionally, we moved the competition to mid-April this year in the hopes that we can avoid some of the travel conflicts associated with previous Madison Cups. We are hopeful that this will be the strongest field that we have hosted thus far, so please enter early.
 
Eligible Participants:  Each school may enter one two-person team.  The debate is open to undergraduate students who are in good standing at their respective institutions.  Second teams will be considered on a case-by-case basis, if space permits.  

Competition Format:  The debate uses a “long table” format.  This is a public debate.   Last year there was an audience of around 500 people for the final round, preliminary rounds were smaller (audiences of 20-30 people).   The “long table” format features three (two person) teams on each side of the question.  Speeches start with the affirmative and alternate between the affirmative and negative throughout the debate.  Teams are randomly assigned to sides and speaker positions.  In other words, if a team is selected to be the first affirmative, they will give the first two affirmative speeches in the debate.  The first and last speeches on each side of the question are uninterruptible.  Any member of the opposing team may interrupt the speeches in the middle of the debate in order to ask the speaker to yield to a question.  Speakers are not required to answer these questions (although not answering questions may cause the audience to think that the speaker is “dodgy”).  Please see the example format below for more information.  You can view last year’s final round at: http://www.jmu.edu/orgs/debate/madisonCup/index.html

Jury Adjudication Procedure:  A three to seven member panel, or jury, will adjudicate the debate.  Juries will be comprised of local residents, students, professors, distinguished JMU alumni, and special invited guests.  At the completion of the debate, the panel will adjourn to discuss, deliberate and decide upon the winners as a group.  The jury votes for (2-person) teams, not sides of the question.  In other words, first place could go to an affirmative team, while second place could be awarded to a negative team.  
 

Tournament Procedures:

*Number of rounds: This year we will offer two preliminary rounds of debate and one final round.

*Switch side debate: Each team will debate at least once on the affirmative and once on the negative.  

*Side & position:  Sides (affirmative or negative), and positions (first affirmative team, first negative team, second affirmative team, etc) for the preliminary debates will be determined by random drawing.

*Judging: Judges will rank teams 1-6 in each preliminary debate, and assign each team quality points based on a thirty-point scale (1-30).

*Advancing to the final round: The six teams with the lowest total ranks will advance to the final round.  Quality points will be used to break ties.

*Sides and Speaking Positions in the final round:  Sides and speaking positions in the final round will be based on seeding after the preliminary rounds.  For example, the first seeded team will choose their “side and position,” then the second seed will choose “side and position,” and so on.

Public Participation:  While the jury deliberates, the floor will be opened for audience comments and speeches.  An award for the best floor speech will be presented.  Local newspapers, politicians, and the general public are invited.

Awards:  The first place team will leave with the Madison Cup—a very nice traveling trophy. Once again this year there is a $15,000.00 purse of prize money.  All participants in the final round will be recognized with awards.

      Prize money will be awarded as follows:
      1st place: $5000.00 donation to your debate program
      2nd place: $3000.00 donation to your debate program
      3rd place: $2000.00 donation to your debate program
      4th—6th place: $1000.00 donation to your debate program
7th-10th place: $500.00 donation to your debate program

We are excited this year to add additional prize money for the student competitors. Any student who participates in the final round will receive a prize to be distributed in the form of a scholarship. The top two teams will receive $1,000 per student and the remaining students in the final round will receive $500.

Entry:  There are no entry fees. We can accommodate a field of 36 teams.  Entry is on a first come, first serve basis.  The first 18 teams to enter are guaranteed a spot in the field, after that we will accept teams, if we can generate a field divisible by 4 or 6.  Deadline for entry is March 15th.  This is necessary so we can determine how many debates there will be in each round.  Send school info, team info (first and last names of debaters) and requests for additional teams to:  Dr. Mike Davis, <davismk@jmu.edu>

Lodging: We have reserved a block of hotel rooms at two area hotels. Both rates will be available until March 18th.

The Best Western Inn.  The phone number for the Best Western is 540-433-6089.  The rate for 1-4 people per room is $54.00 + tax.  When calling the Best Western Inn please mention that you are attending the Madison Cup debates at JMU.

The Comfort Inn. The phone number for The Comfort Inn is (540) 433-6066. The rate is 1-4 people per room is $76 + tax. When calling please mention that you are attending the Madison Cup debates at JMU.

Travel:  James Madison University is located in Harrisonburg, VA, which is two hours southwest of Washington, D.C. on I-81.  If you plan to fly consider Dulles and Washington National/Reagan Airports in Washington DC (2 hours away), Richmond airport (2 hours away), Charlottesville airport (one hour away) and the Shenandoah Regional Airport (15 minutes away).  We will arrange transport from Shenandoah and Charlottesville, and we’ll do our best to work with you from the others.

Schedule:

Wednesday, April 21st, 2010:  James Madison Commemorative Debate and Citizens Forum

7:30 AM: Pick up at the Best Western, Comfort Inn or Warsaw Street Parking Deck (no parking on campus)
8:00 AM  registration and Announcements
8:30 AM: Preliminary debate round 1
11:00 AM Preliminary debate round 2
1:00 PM Lunch
2:30PM: Preliminary debate round 3 (announcement of the final round participants)
5:00 PM: Final round (followed by the presentation of the Madison Cup)


Example Debate Format: The 2004 final round proceeded as follows.

1st Affirmative Speech (Wake Forest #1): (4 minutes) uninterrupted

1st Negative Speech (George Mason #1): (4 minutes) uninterrupted

2nd Affirmative Speech (Wake Forest  #2): (5 minutes):  The first and last minute of the speech are uninterruptible.  In the 2nd-4th minutes of the speech any opposition debater may ask the speaker to yield to a question.  The speaker may accept, or decline the question.

2nd Negative Speech (George Mason #2): (5 minutes): The first and last minute of the speech are uninterruptible.  In the 2nd-4th minutes of the speech any opposition debater may ask the speaker to yield to a question.  The speaker may accept, or decline the question.

3rd Affirmative Speech (Georgetown # 1): (5 minutes): The first and last minute of the speech are uninterruptible.  In the 2nd-4th minutes of the speech any opposition debater may ask the speaker to yield to a question.  The speaker may accept, or decline the question.

3rd Negative Speech (James Madison #1): (5 minutes): The first and last minute of the speech are uninterruptible.  In the 2nd-4th minutes of the speech any opposition debater may ask the speaker to yield to a question.  The speaker may accept, or decline the question.

4th Affirmative Speech (Georgetown #2): (5 minutes) The first and last minute of the speech are uninterruptible.  In the 2nd-4th minutes of the speech any opposition debater may ask the speaker to yield to a question.  The speaker may accept, or decline the question.

4th Negative Speech (James Madison #2): (5 minutes) The first and last minute of the speech are uninterruptible.  In the 2nd-4th minutes of the speech any opposition debater may ask the speaker to yield to a question.  The speaker may accept, or decline the question.

5th Affirmative Speech (Mary Washington #1):  (5 minutes) The first and last minute of the speech are uninterruptible.  In the 2nd-4th minutes of the speech any opposition debater may ask the speaker to yield to a question.  The speaker may accept, or decline the question.

5th Negative Speech (Towson #1): The first and last minute of the speech are uninterruptible.  In the 2nd-4th minutes of the speech any opposition debater may ask the speaker to yield to a question.  The speaker may accept, or decline the question.

6th Affirmative Speech (Mary Washington #2):  (4 minutes) Uninterrupted

6th Negative Speech (Towson University #2):  (4 minutes) Uninterrupted




« Last Edit: February 03, 2010, 02:59:49 PM by Mike Davis » Logged
Pages: [1]
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.21 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!