You are here

Amendment

Streamlining the Topic Selection Process

Current Text

IV. Topic Selection

Section 2: By May 1 the committee will report to the Executive Secretary no fewer than three problem areas to be voted upon by the general membership. In early July the committee will report to the Executive Secretary no fewer than three resolutions corresponding to the winning topic area.

Amendment Text (redactions struck through, additions in red.):

Amendment: 

Removal of the NDT Rep from the Topic Committee

Current Text:

IV. Topic Selection

Amendment: 

Removal of the ADA Rep from the Topic Committee

Current Text:

IV. Topic Selection

Amendment: 

Novice Eligibility

Rationale:

Amendment: 

CEDA Annual Awards

See attachment for text of amendment.
Amendment: 

Sweepstakes Procedures

Proposed amendment:

10. Novice sweepstakes: CEDA will award novice sweepstakes trophies to the top three programs earning the most points in the novice division but not earning enough points to be included in the Top 10 Overall Sweepstakes Awards. Schools will receive points for all teams entered in the novice division. Otherwise, points for novice sweepstakes will be awarded following the guidelines for general sweepstakes. In the event that the junior varsity and novice divisions are collapsed, points will be awarded to teams that debate in novice breakout elimination rounds.

Amendment: 

CEDA Sanctioning

Proposed Amendment:

V. TOURNAMENT SANCTIONING
Section 12: For a tournament to receive CEDA sanctioning and qualify for CEDA points, the host school must be an institutional member of CEDA.

Rationale: Amends the constitution to require tournament hosts be CEDA members to receive CEDA sanctioning. This proposal should take affect beginning the 2018 academic season.

Amendment: 

Ranked-Choice Voting

Amends the election procedures to use ranked-choice voting instead of plurality voting. The rationale is that plurality voting for single-positions with more than two candidates or choices creates vote-splitting and can result in the lesser-preferred candidate or choice being selected. This is particularly true when voters have very little information about how others intend to vote. Ranked-choice voting is resistant to tactical voting and is a much more robust system for determining the will of the voting population. We already use it for the topic vote.

Amendment: 

Amendment process

Add new section to Article VIII. Amendments to the constitution and bylaws.
Section 4. Amendments by the Executive Council.
A. An amendment to the constitution or bylaws may be proposed by a two-thirds vote of the Executive Council.
B. The proposed amendment shall be distributed to the membership for review.
C. After at least 30 days of review, the Executive Secretary will distribute a ballot containing the proposed amendment.
D. The amendment will pass with a majority of those voting.

Amendment: 

CEDA Nats eligibility

AMEND:
Article X, Section 2
Section 2: Students may participate in no more than five National CEDA Tournaments.

Article X, Section 4. A. 3
3. That a student competing for a certain school has already participated in five National CEDA Tournaments.

Rationale: If we are going to allow students to debate for five years we should allow them to debate in our national tournament five times. Unlike the NDT allowing additional debaters into our national tournament does not trade off with other students attending.

Amendment: 

Pages

Subscribe to RSS - Amendment